Which of the above images seems to have the better shadows?
I ask because of the convergence of two bits of information
today.
First, on the Freakonomics podcast there was a discussion on
how your cultural background can affect your view of the world (e.g. pessimistic
vs optimistic). Professor of Psychology,
Boaz Keysar, stated that he was “much more likely to invest in the stock market
when I do it in English. If I think about it in Hebrew, I’m much more
conservative.” My own experience with dual language friends agrees with that;
the language used brought out a slightly different character.
Second, I had lunch with an old friend who taught
architectural drawing for 20 years. He said that he gave an assignment for a
drawing exercise, and stipulated that the light should come from the left. Two
Israeli women turned in projects with the light coming from the right. They
explained that it simply looked better that way. And, after finding that the
rest of the English speaking class preferred the left light, he realized that
Hebrew is written right to left, exactly opposite to English.
Coincidence?
Well… yes and no.
In both examples the culture probably makes some difference,
but I can’t imagine that the difference is overwhelming, or even consistent.
As with my teaching friend, the accepted light angle for
rendering elevations at the Ecole des Beaux Art was always a 45 degree angle
from the upper left toward the lower right. However, a perspective is a
different animal. When I find a perspective in my books from the Beaux Art era (which
isn’t often), the light angle is often from the left, but is nearly as often
from the right, or simply indeterminate. The perspectivists who were trained at
the turn of the last century took their lighting cues from building orientation
and the needs of composition. Goodhue and Ferriss have already been covered in
this blog, but are worth revisiting in this regard.
Out of curiosity I reviewed a quarter of the drawings I did
over 30 years. Of the 120 drawings and paintings, I found that 50 involved
light from the left, 35 used light from the right, and another 35 had either
indeterminate light direction or were lit artificially.
This seems to leave the question up in the air, but if any
reader has an anecdote relating to language, culture and lighting please leave
a comment.
4
It is not everyone's business to write such a great post, one person in a million can write such a beautiful post and you are one of those millions. I hope that you will write more beautiful posts in life and also hope that you will keep climbing the ladder of achievement in your life, very few people do this but I have full hope from you.
ReplyDeleteDLF Phase 3 Escorts Service
Call Girls In Sector 65
escort gallery in gurugram
escorts services in phase 2
Escorts Service in DLF Phase 4
Escorts service in Calangute Beach
Escorts Service in Palolem Beach
gurgaon call girls
neemrana call girls
call girls in gurugram